Saturday, September 13, 2025

MAT8 Q2W7D3: Triangle Comparisons & Indirect Proof

Triangle Comparisons & Indirect Proof

By the end of the lesson, you will be able to:

  1. Use exterior-angle and side-angle comparisons to order sides and angles in a triangle and justify each comparison in at least 8 items with ≥ 85% accuracy, writing comparisons like C>B and a>b.
  2. Apply indirect proof (proof by contradiction) to show that a proposed triangle configuration is impossible (e.g., assuming ab when given A>B) in at least 2 structured proofs with all steps clearly stated.
  3. Solve real-world comparison problems (design-navigation-sports) by deciding which opposite side or included angle is larger using triangle-inequality ideas (within-triangle ordering + hinge logic) in at least 5 word problems with complete justifications.
  • Exterior angle - an angle formed by extending one side of a triangle.
  • Remote interior angles - the two non-adjacent interior angles to a given exterior angle.
  • Exterior-angle comparison - in any triangle, an exterior angle is greater than each of its remote interior angles: ext>remote1 and ext>remote2.
  • Side-angle order (within one triangle) - larger side ↔ larger opposite angle.
  • Included angle - the angle formed by two given sides.
  • Indirect proof (contradiction) - assume the negation of what you want to prove and derive a contradiction.

A) Identify the included angle
In ΔABC, for sides AB and AC, name the included angle.

Show Answer The angle formed by the two sides at their common endpoint: A.

B) Order angles from sides
In ΔPQR, suppose PQ>PR>QR. Order the angles from largest to smallest.

Show Answer Longest side PQ faces the largest angle R; next PRQ; shortest QRP. So R>Q>P.

C) Hinge logic
Two triangles share AB=DE and AC=DF. If A>D, compare BC and EF.

Show Answer With the same two adjacent sides, the triangle with the larger included angle has the longer opposite side: BC>EF.

1) Orientation - why today’s ideas matter

You already know how sides and angles pair up in a triangle: the longest side faces the largest angle, and the shortest side faces the smallest angle. Today you push deeper by using exterior angles and indirect proof to make sharper comparisons without measuring with a protractor or ruler.

Picture a simple tripod. Two legs are fixed to the ground; a third leg is adjustable. When you widen one joint slightly, the angle at that joint grows, so the side across from it changes. This is the heart of within-triangle comparisons. Exterior angles add a new tool: by stepping outside the triangle at one vertex, you gain a comparison that is often quicker than juggling all three interior angles.

Targets for this Explore

  • Use the exterior-angle inequality to compare angles quickly.
  • Use side-angle order to rank sides or angles in one triangle without calculation.
  • Prove comparisons with indirect proof (contradiction) when a direct route is not obvious.
  • Apply all of the above to real-life frames, braces, routes, and team spacing.

2) Exterior angle - the key comparison you can use immediately

Extend one side of a triangle at a vertex. The angle formed outside, adjacent to the interior angle at that vertex, is an exterior angle. In any triangle, an exterior angle is greater than each of its two remote interior angles. More precisely:

  • If the exterior angle is at vertex A along side AB extended, then A_ext>B and A_ext>C.

A stronger fact for reasoning is the equality of measures: A_ext=B+C. For inequalities you mostly need that the exterior angle is greater than each remote interior angle.

Quick intuition - when you open the side past the triangle, you add to the interior angle at that vertex, creating a new angle whose measure is the sum of the two interior angles opposite it. A sum of two positive angles must exceed either one alone.

Guided check E1 - In ΔPQR, extend side PR beyond R to make exterior angle R_ext. Which angles are the remote interior angles relative to R_ext, and what are the two basic inequalities you can write immediately?

Show Answer The remote interior angles are P and Q. The inequalities are R_ext>P and R_ext>Q.

Worked walk-through 1 - In ΔABC, suppose B=37°, C=68°. Extend side CA past A to form A_ext. Since A_ext=B+C, A_ext=37°+68°=105°. Therefore A_ext>B and A_ext>C.

Guided check E2 - In ΔXYZ, suppose Y=51°, Z=64°. Form the exterior angle at X by extending XZ. Compute X_ext and record the two inequalities.

Show Answer X_ext=Y+Z=51°+64°=115°. Thus X_ext>Y and X_ext>Z.

Mini-summary A - Exterior angles offer instant comparisons: the exterior at a vertex is larger than each remote interior angle. When numbers are given, you can add the two remote interior angles to get the exterior measure.


3) Side-angle order within one triangle - pairing that never fails

In any triangle, larger side ↔ larger opposite angle. If a is opposite A, b opposite B, and c opposite C, then a>bA>B and similar statements cycling through.

Worked walk-through 2 - Given ΔMNP with sides MN=7, NP=12, PM=9, order the angles: longest side is 12 → largest angle M; next is 9 → N; smallest is 7 → P. So M>N>P.

Guided check S1 - Inside ΔRST, suppose R>T. Compare sides ST and RS.

Show Answer The side opposite the larger angle is longer. Opposite R is ST; opposite T is RS. Therefore ST>RS.

Mini-summary B - Within any triangle, order sides and angles together: the biggest angle faces the biggest side, and the smallest faces the smallest.


4) Exterior-angle comparisons + side-angle order = fast rankings

Exterior angles let you compare interior angles that are not obviously related. Combine both tools.

Example blend - In ΔABC, create the exterior at A. If you know B and C, then A_ext>B and A_ext>C. Inside the triangle, this often helps locate the largest interior angle among A, B, C, because A and A_ext are a linear pair.

Guided check E3 - In ΔJKL, you extend side JL to form L_ext. If J=40°, K=61°, compute L_ext and decide which of J or K is larger. Then state which side is longest.

Show Answer L_ext=J+K=101°. Here K is larger than J, so the longest side is opposite K, namely JL.

Mini-summary C - Exterior angles can help you compare interiors quickly; then use side-angle pairing to locate the longest or shortest side.


5) Indirect proof - when a direct path is awkward

Sometimes a comparison is not obvious. Indirect proof allows you to assume the opposite of what you want, and then show this leads to something impossible in a triangle, like side-angle order being violated.

Template - Goal: prove A>B. Assume the opposite AB. Then by side-angle pairing, the side opposite A is not longer than the side opposite B: ab. If independent facts already require a>b, you have a contradiction. Conclude A>B.

Worked walk-through 3 - In ΔXYZ, you know from construction that XZ>XY. Prove Y>Z indirectly. Assume the opposite YZ. Then by side-angle pairing, XZXY - contradiction. Hence Y>Z.

Guided check IP1 - You want to prove AB>AC in ΔABC. What inequality about angles would you try to prove, and what opposite assumption would you start with?

Show Answer Because sides and opposite angles pair, proving C>B will give AB>AC. Start indirectly by assuming CB and derive a contradiction with given information.

Mini-summary D - Indirect proof flips a comparison, then lets the triangle’s rules force a contradiction.


6) Real-world modeling - quick decisions without exact lengths

Scenario R1 - Folding sign frame
Two struts meet at a hinge at the top of a portable sign. The lower base is the side opposite the hinge angle. If the struts are kept at the same lengths but the hinge opens from 48° to 82°, what happens to the base’s length?

Show Answer With adjacent struts fixed, a larger included angle makes the opposite side longer. The base increases as the hinge opens.

Scenario R2 - Two route options
Two hikers walk legs of 1.2 km and 1.8 km. Route A turns 35° between legs; Route B turns 95°. Which route has a longer start-to-finish straight line?

Show Answer Same two legs; larger included turn gives a longer opposite side. Route B has the longer straight-line distance.

Scenario R3 - Team spacing triangle
Three players form a triangle. Two distances from the pivot are fixed during a drill, while the pivot angle is adjusted. To widen the passing lane opposite the pivot, should the pivot open or close the angle?

Show Answer Open the angle. Increasing the included angle increases the opposite side.

Mini-summary E - Design, navigation, and spacing problems often reduce to deciding which angle or side is larger.


7) Exterior-angle toolkit - four fast uses

  1. Compare interiors quickly via an exterior.
  2. Spot the largest interior when two are known.
  3. Frame impossibility with contradiction when an interior is claimed to exceed its exterior at the same vertex.
  4. Chain inequalities: use exterior-inequality plus side-angle pairing to deduce side comparisons.

Guided check E4 - At vertex A, a student says the interior A is greater than the exterior A_ext. Is that ever possible?

Show Answer No. A_ext=B+C, which exceeds either B or C alone. The interior at A cannot exceed its exterior.

Mini-summary F - Exterior-angle facts are one-step inequality engines. Combine them with side-angle order for immediate side rankings.


8) Worked examples - fully shown solutions

Example W1 - Order angles from sides - In ΔQRS, sides QR=8, RS=11, SQ=9. Conclusion: Q>R>S.

Example W2 - Use an exterior angle - In ΔABC, B=44°, C=59°. Exterior at A is 103°, so A_ext>B, A_ext>C.

Example W3 - Indirect proof - In ΔMNO, given MO>NO, assume NM leading to MONO - contradiction. Hence N>M.

Example W4 - Exterior data determines rankings - In ΔXYZ, X_ext=128°, Y=53°. Then Z=75°, X=52°, so XY>XZ>YZ.

Example W5 - Design scenario conversion - Exterior at P is 120°, Q=45°. Then R=75°, P=60°, and PQ>QR>PR.

Example W6 - Indirect with a real constraint - Given ST>SU, conclude U>T by contradiction.


9) Practice-like checkpoints inside Explore

Checkpoint C1 - In ΔUVW with UV=10, VW=6, WU=8, order the angles from largest to smallest.

Show Answer Longest side UV → largest W; next WUV; smallest VWU. So W>V>U.

Checkpoint C2 - In ΔABC with B=50° and C=63°, form the exterior at A and record the inequalities involving it.

Show Answer A_ext=113°, and A_ext>B, A_ext>C.

Checkpoint C3 - You are told AC>BC. Which angle is larger, and what contradictory assumption would you start with to prove it?

Show Answer Larger angle is opposite the larger side: B>A. Start by assuming BA, then derive ACBC, contradicting the given.

Mini-summary H - Practice the full cycle: read, reason, compare, and if needed assume the opposite to reach a contradiction.


10) Multi-step situations

Situation S1 - Frame with a fixed foot - A folding frame has sides AB and AC fixed and meets at hinge A. The base is BC. The builder measures an angle outside at A - A_ext. Can they still decide whether BC increased or decreased compared to a previous setting?

Show Answer Yes. As A_ext increases, the interior A decreases because they are a linear pair. The base depends on the interior included angle. A larger exterior means a smaller interior, making BC shorter.

Situation S2 - Two designs, same legs - Two sign designs use the same legs, but one has a larger exterior angle at the hinge than the other. Which has the longer base?

Show Answer Larger exterior at the hinge means smaller interior at the hinge. The design with the smaller interior included angle has the shorter base. So the one with the larger exterior has the shorter base.

Mini-summary I - Exterior and interior at the same vertex move in opposite directions.


11) Layered reasoning tasks

Layered Task L1 - In ΔPQR, with P=43°, Q=54°. a) Compute the exterior at R. b) Which side is longest?

Show Answer a) R_ext=97°. b) Largest interior is Q, so longest side PR.

Layered Task L2 - You are told AB>AC. Prove B>A by contradiction.

Show Answer Assume BA. Then ACAB by side-angle pairing, contradicting AB>AC. Thus B>A.

Mini-summary J - When stuck, flip the target inequality and let side-angle pairing expose the contradiction.


12) Common pitfalls

  • Mixing exterior and interior at the same vertex - they are a linear pair.
  • Comparing non-opposite pairs - the size relation always matches the opposite pairing.
  • Forgetting strictness - equal angles give equal opposite sides.
  • Assuming numbers are required - comparisons are often provable without exact measures.

Guided check P1 - A student says: “Because the exterior at A is bigger than B, the side AC is longer than BC.” Is that correct?

Show Answer Not directly. Exterior-angle inequality compares angles, not sides. To compare sides, identify the largest interior angle, then the side opposite that interior is the longest.

Mini-summary K - Use exterior-angle comparisons to rank angles, then switch to side-angle pairing to rank sides.


13) Extended applications

Construction CA1 - Two brace lengths are fixed in a scissor lift. Choose among interior angles 30°, 55°, 95° to get the longest opposite side.

Show Answer The largest interior included angle yields the longest opposite side. Choose 95°.

Sports SP1 - Two players keep fixed distances from a pivot. To enlarge the passing lane opposite the pivot, what adjustment increases the lane length?

Show Answer Increase the interior angle at the pivot to enlarge the opposite side.

Navigation NV1 - Walk 700 m, turn by θ, walk 900 m. How should θ change to maximize start-to-end straight line?

Show Answer Increase the included turn; larger interior angle yields a longer opposite side.

Mini-summary L - Many field decisions become easy once you know whether to open or close the included angle.


14) Synthesis set

Synthesis S1 - In ΔDEF, D=39°, E=63°. a) Compute F_ext. b) Which side is longest?

Show Answer a) F_ext=102°. b) Largest interior is E, so longest side DF.

Synthesis S2 - Indirect - Given DF>EF, prove E>D.

Show Answer Assume ED. Then DFEF, contradicting DF>EF. Therefore E>D.

Mini-summary M - Exterior gives angle comparisons; side-angle pairing converts angle results into side results. Indirect proof closes the loop.


15) Self-check capsule

  1. If X>Y, which is longer: YZ or XZ?
    Show AnswerYZ>XZ because it is opposite the larger angle X.
  2. If the exterior at A equals 120° and one remote interior is 45°, what is the other remote interior?
    Show Answer75° since 45°+x=120°.
  3. If someone claims an interior at A is larger than its exterior at A, what is the flaw?
    Show AnswerThe exterior equals the sum of the two remote interiors, so it must exceed either one alone.

16) Capstone problems

Capstone CP1 - In ΔABC, B=41°, C=72°. a) Find A_ext. b) Which side is the shortest?

Show Answer a) A_ext=113°. b) Smallest interior is B, so the shortest side is AC.

Capstone CP2 - Indirect - Given AB>CB, prove C>A.

Show Answer Assume CA. Then ABCB, contradicting AB>CB. Therefore C>A.

Capstone CP3 - Exterior + pairing - In ΔHIJ, exterior at I is 128° and one remote interior is 50°. a) Find the other remote interior. b) Which side is longest?

Show Answer a) x+50=128x=78°. b) The largest interior is 78°, so the longest side is opposite that angle.

Mini-summary O - The capstones synthesize everything: an exterior addition, side-angle pairing, and indirect proof.


References

  • Big Ideas Math - Inequalities in one triangle; exterior-angle comparisons.
  • MathBitsNotebook - Triangle inequalities, indirect proof outlines.
  • CK-12 - Exterior angle theorem and remote interior angles.
  • Math is Fun - Angle-side relationships in triangles.
  • Open textbooks on Euclidean geometry - Proofs by contradiction in triangle comparisons.

Worked Example 1 - Exterior angle → compare interior angles and sides

In ΔABC, given B=42°, C=71°.

Show Answer

Exterior at A: A_ext=113°. Interior at A: A=67°. Order: C>A>B. Sides: c>a>b.

Worked Example 2 - Order angles from side lengths

Show Answer

With sides 7, 12, 10 opposite J, K, L respectively, the order is J>K>L.

Worked Example 3 - Indirect proof

Show Answer

Given DE>DF, assume FE to get DEDF - contradiction. Hence F>E.

Worked Example 4 - Exterior data determines all angle rankings

Show Answer

With X_ext=128° and Y=53°, get Z=75°, X=52°, and side order XY>XZ>YZ.

Worked Example 5 - Exterior-to-interior conversion in a design scenario

Show Answer

Exterior at P 120° with Q=45° gives R=75°, P=60°, and PQ>QR>PR.

Worked Example 6 - Indirect proof with a real constraint

Show Answer

Given ST>SU, assume UT which implies STSU - contradiction. Therefore U>T.

  1. In ΔABC, A=46°, B=71°, C=63°. Order b, c, a from longest to shortest.
    Show Answerb>c>a by angle order 71°>63°>46°.
  2. In ΔJKL, sides 9, 14, 11. Order J, K, L.
    Show AnswerJ>K>L since 14 > 11 > 9.
  3. In ΔPQR, exterior at P is 118°, Q=47°. Find R and interior at P.
    Show AnswerR=71°, P=62°.
  4. In ΔUVW, if U>V, compare VW and UW.
    Show AnswerVW>UW since opposite the larger angle.
  5. In ΔXYZ, exterior at Z is 130°, X=58°. Find Y, Z, and the longest side.
    Show AnswerY=72°, Z=50°, longest side XZ.
  6. Given AB>CB, prove C>
A (outline).
Show AnswerAssume CAABCB contradiction → conclude C>A.
  • In ΔMNP, M=N, and P is largest. State relation among NP, MP, MN.
    Show AnswerMN>NP=MP.
  • At vertex A, exterior is 124°. a) Find interior at A. b) Can any interior exceed 124°?
    Show Answera) A=56°. b) No, the exterior equals the sum of the remote interiors.
  • Claim check - “Since exterior at S is bigger than R, ST is longer than RT.” Valid?
    Show AnswerInvalid. Compare interiors first, then use side-angle pairing.
  • In ΔCDE, exterior at D is 110° and C=52°. a) Find E and interior at D. b) Order CE, CD, DE.
    Show Answera) E=58°, D=70°. b) CE>CD>DE.
    1. Order sides from angles: A=48°, B=65°, C=67°.
      Show Answerc>b>a.
    2. Order angles from sides: 9, 13, 11.
      Show AnswerP>Q>R.
    3. Exterior at M with N=41°, O=58°.
      Show AnswerM_ext=99°, with inequalities to each remote interior.
    4. True or False: an interior can exceed its adjacent exterior.
      Show AnswerFalse.
    5. MCQ - If UV=UW, which is correct?
      Show AnswerV=W.
    6. Indirect proof outline from AB>CB.
      Show AnswerAssume CA then reach contradiction.
    7. Exterior 136° at K → interior?
      Show AnswerK=44°. None can exceed 136°.
    8. Two plans 80 m and 120 m: 30°, 70° - which gives longer opposite side?
      Show Answer70° gives longer opposite side.
    9. Is interior at a vertex ever equal to its exterior of 100°?
      Show AnswerNo, interior is 80°.
    10. Which side is longest if angles are 59°, 61°, 60°?
      Show AnswerOpposite 61°.
    11. Exterior 123° at C, remote interior 49°. Find the other remote interior and interior at C.
      Show AnswerOther remote 74°, interior 57°.
    12. Angle order M > N > L. Order sides LN, ML, MN.
      Show AnswerLN>ML>MN.
    13. As exterior at A increases with equal sides AD = AE, what happens to DE?
      Show AnswerInterior at A decreases, so DE shortens.
    14. Exterior 112° at J, H=47°. Find I and the longest side.
      Show AnswerI=65°, longest side HJ.
    15. Short proof: if S>T, compare TV and SV.
      Show AnswerOpposite the larger angle is longer: TV > SV.

    Extension 1 - Design Optimization with a Hinge

    Isosceles stand with equal legs AB and AC, base BC. Compare base lengths at 30°, 55°, 80° without computing exact lengths.

    Show Answer Larger included angle → longer opposite side. Short → long: 30° < 55° < 80°.

    Extension 2 - Indirect Proof: Spotting an Impossible Claim

    Show Answer If PQ = PR but Q>R, then PR > PQ by side-angle pairing, contradicting PQ = PR.

    Extension 3 - Exterior Angle Chain Reasoning

    Show Answer With exterior 126° at X and Y=46°, get Z=80°, X=54°, and sides XY>YZ>ZX.

    Extension 4 - Route Planning Threshold

    Show Answer With sides 3 km and 4 km, the smallest angle that guarantees at least 5 km is 90°, since right triangle gives exactly 5; larger angles give more.

    Extension 5 - Create & Solve Your Own Indirect Proof

    Show Answer Sample: Given AB>CB, assume CAABCB contradiction → conclude C>A.

    Write in your notebook. Use the 3-2-1 format to reflect on today’s learning (exterior angles, side-angle order, and indirect proof). Be specific and refer to at least one problem you solved.

    1. 3 insights - three things you now understand about comparing sides and angles in one triangle.
    2. 2 connections - two ways today’s ideas connect to real situations or earlier lessons.
    3. 1 question - one question you still have or one step in an indirect proof you want to practice again.

    (Optional) Sketch a small triangle and label: one interior angle, the adjacent exterior, and the two remote interiors. Add a one-sentence note about how their sizes compare.

    No comments:

    Post a Comment

    Search This Blog

    Powered by Blogger.